
What Chapter 13 Trustees Wish Every Debtor's Attorney Knew
There is a lot of bad information out there about Chapter 13 and about what trustees actually do. So I started asking them directly. The first episode of The Successful Debtor Project: Conversations With Chapter 13 Trustees features David Ruskin, Chapter 13 trustee in the Eastern District of Michigan. He was appointed in 1982 and has spent more than 40 years in the role, after starting his career representing consumer debtors in 7s and 13s.
He had a lot to say about what helps debtors finish their plans. Here is what every debtor's attorney should take from it.
The trustee is not the enemy
The Bankruptcy Code gives the Chapter 13 trustee the duties of a Chapter 7 trustee, minus liquidation, plus one more. The trustee is supposed to assist the debtor in performance under the plan. David admits that phrase puzzled him for years. Nobody talked about it, not judges, not other trustees, not the debtor bar.
What finally clicked for him was behavioral economics. Why do people do what they do? How did they end up needing to file, and what derails them once they are in a plan? Life happens. A client gets laid off, gets hurt, or suddenly has to hire a lawyer for a teenager. A confirmed plan does not protect anyone from that.
Too many debtors see the trustee as someone standing in their way. David has spent years trying to change that, and his approach gives attorneys a model worth borrowing.
Bottom-line budgets instead of line-item fights
His office used to comb through Schedule J line by line. These days it takes a bottom-line approach. As long as the total stays within a reasonable number, the trustee does not micromanage how debtors spend their money. Food costs swing with the seasons. Some families host the holiday dinner, and some just show up for it. Giving debtors more room to manage their own spending is part of helping them succeed.
Milestone emails that lower the temperature
David's office sends short milestone messages at key points in a case.
After the 341 meeting. You did it. There was no exam, you just had to show up.
After confirmation. Now you are on the road to discharge.
Midway through the plan. A checkup reminder, because most cases drift from the plan as written. He encourages attorneys to meet with clients once a year, like an annual physical, to catch things like a forgotten IRS proof of claim.
The final lap. Don't give up. Finish the second financial management course and any local requirements, such as the child support status statements his court requires.
He calls them pats on the back and locker room pep talks. Debtors write back. His office also pushes enrollment in the National Data Center from the very first mailing, so debtors can see their own payments posted. When an anxious debtor gets a simple reply confirming the payment arrived, he says he can practically see their blood pressure drop.
The data says engaged firms earn more
This was the part that stopped me. A longtime analyst in David's office looked at the top two dozen debtor firms in his district from 2017 to 2025. He compared cases that never confirmed, cases that confirmed but did not discharge, and cases that reached discharge.
Firms with a higher share of discharged cases earned more per case. That makes sense when you think about it. Those lawyers stay engaged, monitor their cases, meet with clients and file post-confirmation modifications when life changes. That work gets compensated.
The same study found that the longer a case lasts, the more unsecured creditors receive. Debtors, their attorneys and creditors all win when the plan finishes.
Not every case is filed for a discharge. Some clients file to save a house and catch up a mortgage. But as David put it, those cases are the minority. Most debtors need the discharge, and most do not understand its value.
What David wishes debtor's attorneys would do
When I asked where the debtor bar could improve, he named three things.
Talk with trustees more. Better relations between the debtor bar and the trustees, even if full coordination never happens.
Explain the trustee's role to your clients. Many attorneys never do, and clients fill the gap with fear.
Build your own milestone contacts. Simple check-ins at the same points in the case, coming from you.
Aim for discharge, not confirmation
His biggest takeaway is something he teaches his own staff. The best plan to confirm is one that is likely to reach discharge.
Confirmation is often when an attorney gets paid and closes the file mentally. That is not the finish line for the client. Education and communication carry a case from confirmation to discharge, whether that is a milestone email, a webinar, an orientation or an annual checkup. None of us learned that in law school, where the model is adversarial. Chapter 13 works better when everyone treats education as part of the job.
Watch the full conversation
Watch my full conversation with David Ruskin on YouTube, and subscribe to The Successful Debtor Project: Conversations With Chapter 13 Trustees so you catch the next trustee interview.
